Best place to sell handmade goods: fees on a $40 sale
Handmade sellers usually compare Etsy with their own store and stop there. The fee spread on a $40 item is larger than most people expect — about $6.05 between the cheapest marketplace and the most expensive resale app — and the channel with the lowest fee is not automatically the one that pays.
Ranked by what you keep on a $40 sale
| Platform | Fees | You keep | Effective rate | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify | $1.66 | $38.34 | 4.1% | Own store |
| Depop | $1.77 | $38.23 | 4.4% | Resale app |
| TikTok Shop | $2.40 | $37.60 | 6.0% | Marketplace |
| Etsy | $4.25 | $35.75 | 10.6% | Marketplace |
| eBay | $5.84 | $34.16 | 14.6% | Marketplace |
| Gumroad | $5.96 | $34.04 | 14.9% | Digital products |
| Walmart Marketplace | $6.00 | $34.00 | 15.0% | Marketplace |
| Poshmark | $8.00 | $32.00 | 20.0% | Resale app |
Fees are the full stack for a US seller with a domestic buyer, no ads or boosts, read 11 November 2026. Monthly plans spread over 200 orders; Amazon includes $4.15 FBA fulfilment.
The three lowest-fee options
$1.66 on a $40 sale (4.1%) — you keep $38.34.
Best for: Brands that want their own storefront, customer list and full price control
Watch: The plan fee and the 2% third-party-gateway surcharge are easy to forget; neither shows up as a commission.
$1.77 on a $40 sale (4.4%) — you keep $38.23.
Best for: Vintage, streetwear and Y2K fashion sold to a younger, style-led audience
Watch: Boosted listings cost 12% of the sale, and buyers pay a marketplace fee on top of your price.
$2.40 on a $40 sale (6.0%) — you keep $37.60.
Best for: Impulse products with a strong video hook and a creator-affiliate plan
Watch: The 6% referral fee looks tiny, but most volume arrives through affiliates who take 10–20%, so budget both.
What the fee table does not show
Three costs decide the channel more often than the fee does. First, demand: a marketplace brings buyers, an own store does not, and a 10% fee is cheaper than a 30% ad cost per order. Second, returns: a returned order refunds the price, not always the fee, and a marketplace's return rate in handmade goods is usually higher than a store's. Third, cash timing: marketplaces pay out on a schedule with a reserve, so revenue earned this week may arrive next month, which matters if you are buying inventory.
Other categories
Audit every channel before your next price change
The Ecommerce Multi-Channel Unit Economics & Fee Audit Kit is the Excel version of this site: 19 platforms in one fee matrix, break-even ROAS and max CPA by channel, a 40-SKU margin simulator, bundle and discount math, a 12-month cash-flow forecast and a 30-point fee audit checklist.
Get the kit — $29, launch code LAUNCH25 (−25%)Instant download · Excel .xlsx, works in Excel, Google Sheets and LibreOffice · one-time purchase.
Questions
What is the cheapest platform for handmade goods at $40?
On fees alone, Shopify at $1.66 (4.1%) for a $40 sale. Second is Depop at $1.77 and third TikTok Shop at $2.40.
Does the cheapest platform mean the most profit for handmade goods?
No. A platform with low fees and no buyers earns nothing. The fee is the cost of distribution — compare it with what you would spend on ads to reach the same buyer from your own store.
How much do fees take on a $40 handmade goods sale?
Between 4.1% and 20.0% of the price across the platforms listed here — $6.34 of difference per order.