Shopify vs Etsy: fees and payout side by side
Shopify is cheaper at all 6 price points — Etsy is never cheaper on fees alone, though it brings its own buyers. On a $50 sale you keep $48.05 with Shopify and $44.80 with Etsy, before product cost.
| Sale price | Shopify | Etsy | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| $15 | $0.94 | $1.88 | Shopify by $0.94 |
| $25 | $1.23 | $2.83 | Shopify by $1.60 |
| $50 | $1.95 | $5.20 | Shopify by $3.25 |
| $100 | $3.40 | $9.95 | Shopify by $6.55 |
| $250 | $7.75 | $24.20 | Shopify by $16.45 |
| $500 | $15.00 | $47.95 | Shopify by $32.95 |
Where each one wins
Your own store on a monthly plan, with card fees instead of a commission
Best for: Brands that want their own storefront, customer list and full price control
Watch: The plan fee and the 2% third-party-gateway surcharge are easy to forget; neither shows up as a commission.
Handmade and vintage demand with the lowest headline transaction fee of the big marketplaces
Best for: Handmade, personalised, vintage and digital goods where the buyer wants the item, not the brand
Watch: Offsite Ads at 12–15% on orders they bring in, and the 6.5% transaction fee applies to shipping you charge too.
Fees at each price point
Audit every channel before your next price change
The Ecommerce Multi-Channel Unit Economics & Fee Audit Kit is the Excel version of this site: 19 platforms in one fee matrix, break-even ROAS and max CPA by channel, a 40-SKU margin simulator, bundle and discount math, a 12-month cash-flow forecast and a 30-point fee audit checklist.
Get the kit — $29, launch code LAUNCH25 (−25%)Instant download · Excel .xlsx, works in Excel, Google Sheets and LibreOffice · one-time purchase.
Questions
Is Shopify cheaper than Etsy?
Shopify is cheaper at all 6 price points — Etsy is never cheaper on fees alone, though it brings its own buyers. At $50 the totals are $1.95 on Shopify and $5.20 on Etsy.
Which is better for a $50 product?
On fees alone, Shopify — $1.95 against $5.20. Neither figure includes the cost of getting the buyer there, which is where the two models actually differ.
Do these numbers include ads or boosts?
No. Both are modelled with no advertising: no Etsy Offsite Ads, no Promoted Listings, no TikTok affiliate commission and no paid traffic. Each of those can add 10–20% to the order.