Fee Audit Kit · $29
Fee Hub / Guides / Marketplace or own store

When a marketplace beats your own store

Every seller eventually asks whether to move off Etsy or Amazon onto Shopify. The fee comparison is the easy part: a store takes 2.9% + 30¢ instead of 10–15%. The hard part is that the marketplace's fee buys buyers, and the store's fee buys none.

The fee gap per order

PriceEtsy feesShopify feesDifference per orderOrders to cover the $39 plan
$20$2.35$1.08$1.2731 orders/mo
$35$3.78$1.52$2.2617 orders/mo
$50$5.20$1.95$3.2512 orders/mo
$75$7.58$2.68$4.908 orders/mo
$100$9.95$3.40$6.556 orders/mo

At $35, Etsy takes $3.78 and a Shopify Basic store takes $1.52 once the $39 plan is spread over 200 orders. The saving is $2.26 an order — real, but not the 10% people imagine, because the store still pays card fees.

What the store's saving has to pay for

Traffic. If a $2 saving per order is going to justify moving, the store must acquire orders for less than that in advertising, which means a CPA under $2 — impossible for most products. In practice sellers keep the marketplace and open a store to serve repeat buyers, where the ad cost is zero because the customer already exists.

The break-even order count

The $39 plan is covered when the per-order saving times your monthly orders exceeds it. At $35 the saving is about $2.26, so the plan pays for itself above roughly 17 orders a month — and that is before any ad spend to get those orders. Below that line, the marketplace is cheaper even at a 10% commission.

A rule that survives both cases

Price the same on both channels. A store that undercuts its marketplace listing trains buyers to leave, and the marketplace's algorithm punishes the lower conversion. Keep the marketplace for discovery, the store for retention, and treat the fee difference as the cost of the second channel rather than a saving.

Audit every channel before your next price change

The Ecommerce Multi-Channel Unit Economics & Fee Audit Kit is the Excel version of this site: 19 platforms in one fee matrix, break-even ROAS and max CPA by channel, a 40-SKU margin simulator, bundle and discount math, a 12-month cash-flow forecast and a 30-point fee audit checklist.

Get the kit — $29, launch code LAUNCH25 (−25%)

Instant download · Excel .xlsx, works in Excel, Google Sheets and LibreOffice · one-time purchase.